It’s one of our favorite comparison videos for a reason: strips and extractors both work, they just do different jobs.

Pore strips

Good at: grabbing the tops of surface blackheads and fuzz across a whole area in one go. Best for: quick, low-effort nose sessions and total beginners. Watch out for: using them too often, or on dry, sunburned or irritated skin. Our pick: Bioré strips.

Loop extractors

Good at: precise, one-at-a-time extraction of individual blackheads. Best for: people who want control and a cleaner result on specific spots. Watch out for: pressing too hard or working on inflamed skin. Our pick: the Pore Tube Extractor Kit, or the Tweezerman loop extractor if you want a single tool.

Our verdict

Use a strip as a quick reset, use a loop for the stubborn individual ones, and prep before both. Steam first with a NanoSteamer or a warm cloth and you’ll get more out of either method.

General information, not medical advice. Our videos show one person’s skin. If something is red, painful or inflamed, leave it alone and talk to a dermatologist. Some links are affiliate links; as an Amazon Associate, Pore Tube earns from qualifying purchases.